Back to blog

UTM Tagging vs Other Tracking Methods: A Breakdown

November 17, 2023 | Jimit Mehta

Are you tired of guessing which marketing campaigns are actually driving conversions and sales? Enter UTM tagging and other tracking methods. These tools provide a wealth of data that can help you understand the performance of your campaigns and make informed decisions about your marketing strategy. But with so many options available, it can be difficult to know which one to use. That's where this article comes in. We'll break down UTM tagging and compare it to other tracking methods, so you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

What is UTM Tagging?

UTM tagging is a simple but powerful method of tracking website traffic and analyzing the effectiveness of your online marketing campaigns. In layman's terms, a UTM tag is a code that you add to the end of a URL in order to track where your website visitors are coming from.

Think of it like a GPS for your website traffic. Just like a GPS tracks your physical location, UTM tags track the digital location of your website visitors. This information helps you understand which marketing campaigns are driving the most traffic and conversions, so you can make data-driven decisions about your marketing strategy.

UTM tags are created using five different parameters: source, medium, campaign, term, and content. Each parameter provides additional information about the website visitor, such as which website referred them, what type of marketing campaign they clicked on, and which specific ad or link they interacted with.

Overall, UTM tagging is a valuable tool for any business looking to optimize their online marketing efforts and make data-driven decisions.

Personalize every website interaction
Try for free

What are the benefits of UTM Tagging?

UTM tagging offers a number of benefits for businesses looking to track and optimize their online marketing campaigns. Here are just a few of the most notable benefits:

  1. Improved campaign tracking: UTM tags allow you to track the performance of individual campaigns and see exactly which ones are driving the most traffic and conversions.

  2. Better data analysis: With UTM tagging, you can see which websites are referring the most traffic, which marketing channels are most effective, and which specific ads or links are performing the best.

  3. Increased transparency: UTM tags provide a clear, concise way to track the performance of your campaigns, so you can make informed decisions about your marketing strategy.

  4. Easier reporting: UTM tags make it easy to generate reports that show the performance of your campaigns, so you can quickly see which ones are working and which ones need to be improved.

  5. Better budget allocation: By tracking the performance of your campaigns, you can make informed decisions about where to allocate your marketing budget and focus your efforts on the campaigns that are delivering the best results.

Overall, UTM tagging is a powerful tool for any business looking to track and optimize their online marketing efforts. Whether you're a small business just starting out or a large enterprise with a complex marketing strategy, UTM tags can help you make data-driven decisions and achieve your marketing goals.

How does UTM Tagging work?

UTM tagging works by adding a short code to the end of a URL that you use in your marketing campaigns. The code is made up of five different parameters: source, medium, campaign, term, and content.

Here's how it works:

  1. You create a unique UTM tag for each marketing campaign you want to track.

  2. You add the UTM tag to the end of the URL that you're using in your marketing campaigns. For example, if you're running a Google AdWords campaign, you might add a UTM tag to the URL that people will click on in your ad.

  3. When someone clicks on the URL with the UTM tag, the information in the UTM tag is sent to Google Analytics (or your preferred analytics tool). This information includes the source of the traffic (e.g. Google AdWords), the medium (e.g. pay-per-click), the campaign name (e.g. "Winter Sale"), and any other information you included in the UTM tag.

  4. Google Analytics (or your preferred analytics tool) uses this information to track the performance of your campaigns and provide detailed reports on where your website traffic is coming from and which campaigns are driving the most conversions.

The key to making UTM tagging work is to use a consistent naming convention for your UTM tags, so that you can easily track and compare the performance of your campaigns over time. This will help you make informed decisions about your marketing strategy and optimize your campaigns for the best results.

What are other tracking methods and how do they compare to UTM Tagging?

While UTM tagging is a popular and effective tracking method, it's not the only option available. There are several other tracking methods that businesses can use to track the performance of their online marketing campaigns, including:

  1. Google Analytics tracking code: This is a small piece of code that you add to your website to track your website traffic. It provides detailed reports on website visitors, including their location, the pages they visit, and how they found your site. Google Analytics tracking code is different from UTM tagging in that it tracks all traffic to your website, whereas UTM tagging is used to track specific campaigns.

  2. Campaign-specific tracking links: This is a method of tracking where your website visitors are coming from by using a unique URL for each campaign. For example, if you're running a Facebook ad, you might use a different URL for that ad than you would for a Google AdWords ad. This allows you to track the performance of each campaign separately.

  3. Conversion tracking: This is a way to track when a website visitor takes a specific action, such as filling out a form, making a purchase, or signing up for a newsletter. Conversion tracking can be done through Google Analytics or through other third-party tools.

  4. Phone call tracking: This is a way to track phone calls made to your business as a result of a specific marketing campaign. Phone call tracking uses unique phone numbers for each campaign, so you can see which campaigns are driving the most phone calls.

So, how do these tracking methods compare to UTM tagging? In many ways, they are similar: all of them provide valuable data that can help you track the performance of your campaigns and make informed decisions about your marketing strategy. However, UTM tagging is often considered the simplest and most cost-effective tracking method, since it can be implemented quickly and easily and provides a wealth of data that can be analyzed in Google Analytics.

Ultimately, the right tracking method for your business will depend on your specific needs and goals. If you're looking for a simple, cost-effective way to track your campaigns, UTM tagging might be the best choice. But if you need more detailed information about your website visitors or want to track specific actions, such as phone calls or conversions, you might want to consider using another tracking method.

Google Analytics and UTM Tagging

Google Analytics and UTM tagging are two powerful tools that work together to provide detailed information about your website traffic and marketing campaigns. Google Analytics is a free website analytics service offered by Google that provides detailed reports on website visitors, including their location, the pages they visit, and how they found your site. UTM tagging, on the other hand, is a method of tracking where your website visitors are coming from by adding a code to the end of a URL that you use in your marketing campaigns.

When you use UTM tags in your marketing campaigns, the information in the UTM tags is sent to Google Analytics. Google Analytics then uses this information to track the performance of your campaigns and provide detailed reports on where your website traffic is coming from and which campaigns are driving the most conversions.

One of the biggest benefits of using Google Analytics and UTM tagging together is that it provides a comprehensive view of your website traffic and marketing campaigns. With this information, you can make informed decisions about your marketing strategy and optimize your campaigns for the best results.

In order to use Google Analytics and UTM tagging together, you'll need to set up a Google Analytics account and add the Google Analytics tracking code to your website. Then, you can start using UTM tags in your marketing campaigns and analyzing the results in Google Analytics.

Overall, Google Analytics and UTM tagging are a powerful combination that can help any business track and optimize their online marketing efforts. Whether you're a small business just starting out or a large enterprise with a complex marketing strategy, these tools can help you make data-driven decisions and achieve your marketing goals.

Advantages of using other tracking methods

While UTM tagging is a popular and effective tracking method, it may not be the best choice for every business. There are several other tracking methods available, each with its own set of advantages. Here are a few of the most notable advantages of using other tracking methods:

  1. More detailed information: Some tracking methods, such as conversion tracking, provide more detailed information about website visitors and their actions. This can be especially useful for businesses looking to understand the behavior of their website visitors and optimize their conversion rate.

  2. Ability to track specific actions: Other tracking methods, such as phone call tracking, allow you to track specific actions, such as phone calls made to your business. This can be especially useful for businesses looking to measure the impact of their marketing campaigns on phone calls and sales.

  3. Integration with other tools: Some tracking methods, such as Google Analytics tracking code, are integrated with other tools, such as Google AdWords. This can make it easier to track the performance of your campaigns and make data-driven decisions.

  4. Customization options: Some tracking methods, such as campaign-specific tracking links, offer more customization options and can be tailored to the specific needs of your business.

Ultimately, the right tracking method for your business will depend on your specific goals and needs. If you're looking for a simple and cost-effective way to track your campaigns, UTM tagging might be the best choice. But if you need more detailed information or want to track specific actions, such as phone calls or conversions, another tracking method might be a better fit.

Choosing the right tracking method for your business

With so many tracking methods available, it can be difficult to know which one is right for your business. Here are some factors to consider when choosing the right tracking method:

  1. Your goals: What do you hope to achieve with your tracking method? Are you looking to track the performance of specific campaigns, understand the behavior of your website visitors, or measure the impact of your marketing efforts on sales? Understanding your goals will help you choose the tracking method that best fits your needs.

  2. The type of business you have: Different tracking methods are better suited for different types of businesses. For example, phone call tracking might be a good fit for a business that relies heavily on phone sales, while conversion tracking might be a better fit for a business that sells products online.

  3. Your budget: Some tracking methods, such as phone call tracking, can be more expensive than others, such as UTM tagging. Consider your budget when choosing a tracking method to ensure that you're getting the best value for your money.

  4. The level of detail you need: Some tracking methods, such as UTM tagging, provide a high-level view of your website traffic, while others, such as conversion tracking, provide more detailed information about website visitors and their actions. Consider the level of detail you need when choosing a tracking method.

  5. Your technical expertise: Some tracking methods, such as UTM tagging, are relatively simple to set up and use, while others, such as phone call tracking, can be more complex. Consider your technical expertise when choosing a tracking method to ensure that you're able to implement it effectively.

By considering these factors and understanding your goals, you'll be able to choose the right tracking method for your business and ensure that you're getting the most value from your tracking efforts.

Best practices for implementing UTM Tagging or other tracking methods

Implementing UTM tagging or other tracking methods is an important step in optimizing your online marketing efforts. Here are some best practices to keep in mind when implementing UTM tagging or other tracking methods:

  1. Use a consistent naming convention: When creating UTM tags or using other tracking methods, use a consistent naming convention for each campaign. This will make it easier to track the performance of your campaigns and make data-driven decisions.

  2. Test your tracking codes: Before launching a marketing campaign, test your UTM tags or other tracking codes to make sure they're working properly. This will help you avoid any tracking errors and ensure that you're getting accurate data.

  3. Track all relevant campaigns: Make sure to track all relevant campaigns, including social media, email, and other marketing efforts. This will give you a comprehensive view of your marketing performance and help you make informed decisions.

  4. Use tools to automate the process: There are tools available that can automate the process of creating UTM tags or using other tracking methods. These tools can save you time and help ensure that you're using best practices when tracking your campaigns.

  5. Regularly review and analyze your data: Regularly review and analyze the data from your UTM tags or other tracking methods. This will help you identify trends and make informed decisions about your marketing strategy.

  6. Make changes based on data: Use the data from your UTM tags or other tracking methods to make informed changes to your marketing strategy. This will help you optimize your campaigns for the best results.

By following these best practices, you'll be able to effectively implement UTM tagging or other tracking methods and make data-driven decisions about your marketing strategy. Whether you're a small business just starting out or a large enterprise with a complex marketing strategy, these best practices will help you optimize your online marketing efforts and achieve your marketing goals.

Common mistakes to avoid when using tracking methods

Using tracking methods is a powerful way to optimize your online marketing efforts, but it's important to avoid common mistakes in order to get the most value from your tracking efforts. Here are a few common mistakes to avoid when using tracking methods:

  1. Not using a consistent naming convention: When creating UTM tags or using other tracking methods, it's important to use a consistent naming convention for each campaign. Not using a consistent naming convention can make it difficult to track the performance of your campaigns and make data-driven decisions.

  2. Not testing tracking codes: Before launching a marketing campaign, make sure to test your UTM tags or other tracking codes to make sure they're working properly. Not testing your tracking codes can lead to tracking errors and inaccurate data.

  3. Not tracking all relevant campaigns: Make sure to track all relevant campaigns, including social media, email, and other marketing efforts. Not tracking all relevant campaigns can give you an incomplete view of your marketing performance and make it difficult to make informed decisions.

  4. Not regularly reviewing and analyzing data: Regularly review and analyze the data from your UTM tags or other tracking methods. Not doing so can prevent you from identifying trends and making informed decisions about your marketing strategy.

  5. Not making changes based on data: Use the data from your UTM tags or other tracking methods to make informed changes to your marketing strategy. Not doing so can prevent you from optimizing your campaigns for the best results.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you'll be able to effectively use UTM tagging or other tracking methods and make data-driven decisions about your marketing strategy. Whether you're a small business just starting out or a large enterprise with a complex marketing strategy, avoiding these mistakes will help you optimize your online marketing efforts and achieve your marketing goals.

The future of tracking methods and how they will impact digital marketing

Tracking methods have come a long way in recent years and are likely to continue to evolve in the future. As technology continues to advance, tracking methods will become even more sophisticated and provide more detailed information about website visitors and marketing campaigns.

Here are a few ways that the future of tracking methods is likely to impact digital marketing:

  1. Increased personalization: With more detailed tracking data, businesses will be able to personalize their marketing efforts and deliver more relevant and targeted messages to their audience. This will lead to increased engagement and conversions.

  2. Improved attribution: Improved tracking methods will provide a more comprehensive view of the customer journey and make it easier to attribute conversions to specific marketing efforts. This will help businesses make data-driven decisions about their marketing strategy.

  3. Greater automation: As tracking methods become more sophisticated, businesses will be able to automate many aspects of their tracking and reporting process. This will save time and make it easier to track the performance of campaigns and make data-driven decisions.

  4. Better data privacy: As privacy concerns continue to be a major issue, tracking methods will evolve to ensure that personal data is protected and used responsibly. This will be important for businesses looking to build trust with their customers and comply with privacy regulations.

Overall, the future of tracking methods is likely to bring significant advancements and improvements to the field of digital marketing. Whether you're a small business just starting out or a large enterprise with a complex marketing strategy, these advancements will help you optimize your online marketing efforts and achieve your marketing goals.

Over to you

Tracking the performance of online marketing campaigns is crucial for any business looking to optimize their efforts and achieve their marketing goals. There are several tracking methods available, including UTM tagging and others such as Google Analytics tracking code, campaign-specific tracking links, conversion tracking, and phone call tracking. Each tracking method has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the right method for a business will depend on their specific needs and goals.

UTM tagging is a popular and effective tracking method that provides a high-level view of website traffic and the performance of specific campaigns. Other tracking methods, such as conversion tracking, can provide more detailed information about website visitors and their actions. The future of tracking methods is likely to bring advancements in personalization, attribution, automation, and data privacy.

In conclusion, choosing the right tracking method for your business is an important step in optimizing your online marketing efforts. Whether you choose UTM tagging or another tracking method, it's important to follow best practices and avoid common mistakes in order to get the most value from your tracking efforts.

Want to use UTM tags to personalize your website for different campaigns? Try Markettailor for free.


Related posts

UTM Tagging vs Traditional Tracking Methods: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Tracking your website's performance and marketing efforts can be a crucial aspect of running a successful business. With the multitude of tools and methods available, it can be overwhelming to determine which one is best for your needs. Two popular methods for tracking website data are UTM tagging...

Read more

How UTM tags can help you measure the success of your video marketing efforts

Video marketing is a powerful tool for businesses to reach and engage with their target audience. With the rise of platforms like YouTube and TikTok, businesses are now able to create and distribute videos on a massive scale, making it easier than ever to reach a global audience. However, with so...

Read more